How to plot fitted meta regression lines on a scatter plot when using metafor and ggplot2 1 can datapoints be colored in funnel plot based on category in metafor packager. This report presents guidance to authors wishing to submit graphical displays as part of their metaanalysis to a clinical cardiology journal, such as heart. The labbe plot is one of several graphs commonly used to display data visually in a metaanalysis of clinical trials that compare a treatment and a control intervention. As compared with other graphic procedures, the labbe plot is useful to identify not only the studies having different results from other studies, but also the study arms that. The model specified via x must be a model without moderators i. In a funnel plot, the weight of each study, the sample size, or the inverse of the variance is plotted against the size of its treatment effect in a metaanalysis. Mar, 2019 a great feature of metafor is the publication ready graphics including forest plots, funnel plots, galbraith plots, and the labbe plot. Charting the landscape of graphical displays for meta. Mix pro is professional software for metaanalysis that runs within excel 2007 and excel 2010. In the last twenty years, similar metaanalytical techniques. Ive written a couple programs that help people run a meta analysis and are all based on metafor and r.
The meta analysis function of jasp is based on the aforementioned metafor r package. Forest plots, funnel plots and labbe plots can be drawn and statistical tests for funnel plot asymmetry can be computed. Stata module for fixed and random effects metaanalysis. Datavisualization methods are essential to explore and communicate metaanalytic data and results. Metaanalysis software forest plot radial plot ncss. An updated collection from the stata journal, second edition.
Mix pro is professional software for meta analysis that runs within excel 2007 and excel 2010. Commercial specialist software is available, but may be expensive and focused in a particular type of primary data. A number of plots have been devised to display the information in a metaanalysis. Typically, in meta analysis measures like risk ratios, odds ratios, and even risk differences are used to compute effect measures. As of stata 16, stata has an official suite of metaanalysis commands.
As compared with other graphic procedures, the l abbe plot is useful to identify not only the studies having different results from other studies, but also the study arms that. By using a published meta analysis as an example, this paper discusses the use of l abbe plot for investigating the potential sources of heterogeneity in meta analysis. Userfriendly general package providing standard methods for metaanalysis and supporting schwarzer. An updated collection from the stata journal, second edition, which brought together all the stata journal articles about the. I am wondering how a labbe plot can guide us towards which one to use. Either binary event or continuous data from two groups may be combined using the metan command. This plots the event rate in the experimental intervention group against the event rate in the control group, as an aid to exploring the heterogeneity of effect estimates within a metaanalysis song, 1999. Graphical displays play a pivotal role in understanding data sets and disseminating results. In the example below, the points show the log risk of a tuberculosis infection in the treatment x axis and control y axis group. What are the main reasons to use r software for meta.
Using published meta analyses as examples, this paper compared the cochrane plot and the l abbe plot for the investigation of heterogeneity between individual. A l abbe plot is a scatter plot with the risk in the control group on the xaxis and the risk in the experimental group on the yaxis l abbe et al. This is a fully functional version, except users cannot create or load custom datasets. L abbe plot for meta analysis with binary outcome data baujat plot to explore heterogeneity in meta analysis bubble plot to display the result of a meta regression. The plot can be used in metaanalysis to check the normality of the data dots expected on a straight line, to investigate heterogeneity clustering of dots, and to assess the presence of publication bias deviation of the tails from the regression line. Within demo files, select files from the language directory appropriate for your computers language settings.
Jasp is a free, opensource program used to perform statistical analysis tests by using r packages. A comprehensive collection of functions for conducting meta analyses in r. The tool can be downloaded from the accompanying website. Is there any way to perform a meta analysis on single arm. More will be said about each of these plots in the output section. For metaanalysis, they are instrumental in presenting findings from multiple studies. It is basically a scatterplot of results of individual studies with the risk in the treatment. Although the scatter plot is a nice way of plotting the events rate in the treatment group against the control group and it is visually appealing for readers, it was in fact introduced in an attempt to solve one of the problems of reporting meta analysis which is the. In this meta analysis, we evaluated the benefits and disadvantages of ureteral stents for the treatment of ureteral stones. Funnel plot can be useful to assess for bias in a metaanalysis.
Mavis is a shiny app and r package for running a meta analysis in a web browser kylehamilton. This plots the event rate in the experimental intervention group against the event rate in the control group, as an aid to exploring the heterogeneity of effect estimates within a meta analysis song, 1999. The following meta analysis commands are all described in meta analysis in stata. In addition, this paper demonstrates that different methods may identify different trials as outliers and the conclusions of a metaanalysis may change by excluding different studies. It shows the estimate often a risk ratio or odds ratio and confidence interval for each study and, commonly at the bottom, the corresponding summary estimate. Metaanalysis reference manual, especially introduction to metaanalysis introduction to meta metaanalysis in stata. We should suspect the presence of heterogeneity in these data. Comprehensive metaanalysis software does have such facilities because it was designed to deal with a wide variety of studies including, singlearm studies. These routines provide facilities to conduct metaanalyses of data from more than one study and to graph the results. The l abbe plot is one of several graphs commonly used to display data visually in a meta analysis of clinical trials that compare a treatment and a control intervention. To conduct a meta analysis in jasp, be sure to check our their guide. Additionally, intervention effect estimates with corresponding standard errors or confidence intervals may be metaanalysed.
One plot is shown in a 1985 book about meta analysis 252 the first use in print of the expression forest plot may be in an abstract for a poster at the pittsburgh us meeting of the society for clinical trials in may 1996. Can the points be colored in the labbeplot based on. Labbe plot for metaanalysis with binary outcomes in. Both fixed, and random, effects models are available for analysis. Background and aim ureteroscopic lithotripsy url and extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy eswl are two widely used methods for the treatment of ureteral stones. These include the forest plot, the radial plot, and the labbe plot. With a large number of novel graphs proposed quite recently, a comprehensive, uptodate overview of available graphing options for metaanalysis is unavailable. Ncss performs metaanalysis based on the methods outlined in sutton et al 2000 and thompson 1998. The package includes functions to calculate various effect sizes or outcome measures, fit fixed, random, and mixedeffects models to such data, carry out moderator and meta regression analyses, and create various types of meta analytical plots e. A forest plot, also known as a blobbogram, is a graphical display of estimated results from a number of scientific studies addressing the same question, along with the overall results. Graphical plots for investigating heterogeneity in meta. Metaanalysis of stenting versus nonstenting for the.
When using graphical displays for metaanalysis, we. We applied a multitiered search strategy to find the metaanalytic graphs proposed and introduced so far. Are there certain features in a l abbe plot that might give us more intuition to which of the three work better. However, despite this large number of newly proposed graphs in recent years, most of the graphs actually used in published metaanalyses date back to the very beginnings of metaanalysis in the 1970s and 1980s e.
What are the main reasons to use r software for metaanalysis. Use the meta suite of commands, or let the control panel interface guide you through your entire meta analysis. A labbe plot is a scatter plot with the risk in the control group on the xaxis and the risk in the experimental group on the yaxis labbe et al. To uninstall the program use the windows control panel, select add or remove programs, and. Assess the impact of publication bias on results with trimandfill analysis. Ive written a couple programs that help people run a metaanalysis and are all based on metafor and r. It is a userfriendly way of conducting stats without having to deal with the r code itself. Are there certain features in a labbe plot that might give us more intuition to which of the three work better. It is basically a scatterplot of results of individual studies with the risk in the treatment group on the vertical axis and the risk in the control group on the horizontal axis. General purpose statistical packages can meta analyze data, but usually require external macros or coding. Typically, in metaanalysis measures like risk ratios, odds ratios, and even risk differences are used to compute effect measures. In their original study, rosenthal and jacobson discovered the socalled pygmalion effect, in which expectations of teachers affected outcomes of their students. An updated collection from the stata journal, second edition by tom m. Each plot is described in the sections that follow.
Userfriendly general package providing standard methods for meta analysis and. Forest plot forest funnel plot funnel galbraith plot radial plot radial labbe plot for metaanalysis with binary outcome data labbe baujat plot to explore heterogeneity in metaanalysis baujat bubble plot to display the result of a metaregression bubble. The need for ureteral stenting during these procedures is controversial. By using a published metaanalysis as an example, this paper discusses the use of labbe plot for investigating the potential sources of heterogeneity in metaanalysis. A labbe plot from the metafor package an additional benefit of using r for metaanalysis is that it facilitates analyses that can be easily reproduced by others, as the software is freely available and r. The box plot, like the normal quantile plot, is also frequently used in statistics. Function to create labbe plots for objects of class rma. A comprehensive collection of functions for conducting metaanalyses in r. Metaanalyses and forest plots using a microsoft excel.
Metaregression models can be used to analyse associations between treatment effect and study characteristics. In addition, this paper demonstrates that different methods may identify different trials as outliers and the conclusions of a meta analysis may change by excluding different studies. The plots include the forest plot, radial plot, and labbe plot. Metaanalysis is a statistical technique, or set of statistical techniques, for summarising the results of several studies into a single estimate. Metaanalysis of hazard ratios statistical software. This plot should be shaped like an inverted funnel if there is no publication bias. The goals of meta analysis may be summarized as follows. The package includes functions to calculate various effect sizes or outcome measures, fit fixed, random, and mixedeffects models to such data, carry out moderator and metaregression analyses, and create various types of metaanalytical plots e. In a funnel plot, the weight of each study, the sample size, or the inverse of the variance is plotted against the size of its treatment effect in a meta analysis. Graphical plots for investigating heterogeneity in metaanalysis. Aug 12, 2017 appendix b provides a detailed overview of the features of the software for meta. My first point is regarding the use of the l abbe plot in metaanalysis.
It was developed for use in medical research as a means of graphically representing a metaanalysis of the results of randomized controlled trials. Comprehensive meta analysis software does have such facilities because it was designed to deal with a wide variety of studies including, singlearm studies. Labbe plot for metaanalysis with binary outcome data baujat plot to explore heterogeneity in metaanalysis bubble plot to display the result of a metaregression. General purpose statistical packages can metaanalyze data, but usually require external macros or coding. Labbe plot can be useful to assess heterogeneity in a metaanalysis. Essentials, which functions as a set of spreadsheet workbooks. Labbe plot can be useful to assess heterogeneity in a metaanalysis funnel plot can be useful to assess for bias in a metaanalysis created over 1 year ago by claudine kumba. Meta analysis has become popular for a number of reasons. We have found many books and articles on meta analysis. To demonstrate the meta suite, we use the famous example from raudenbush of the meta analysis of 19 studies that evaluated the effects of teacher expectancy on pupil iq.
Moreover, the model must be fitted with measure set equal to rd for risk differences, rr for risk ratios, or for odds ratios, as for arcsine square root transformed risk differences, irr. It is meant for those wanting to learn or teach about metaanalysis. See statas full list of official metaanalysis features stata users have also developed numerous excellent commands for performing metaanalyses. A great feature of metafor is the publication ready graphics including forest plots, funnel plots, galbraith plots, and the labbe plot. Metaanalysis of correlated proportions statistical software. The forest plot figure 1, part a is the most common graph in meta analysis reports.
In fact, we did establish inexample 1of meta meta regress that there is at least one moderator, the distancefrom the equator, that explains some of the variation in the trial effect sizes. I am wondering how a l abbe plot can guide us towards which one to use. Mix pro users can create and edit their own data sets in the easy spreadsheet interface of excel. An informative investigation on the origin of the notion forest plot was published in 2001. Using published metaanalyses as examples, this paper compared the cochrane plot and the labbe plot for the investigation of heterogeneity between individual. In this metaanalysis, we evaluated the benefits and disadvantages of ureteral stents for the treatment of ureteral stones.
239 381 1332 1226 1042 600 1303 1130 526 1330 1386 1046 1276 708 123 383 404 338 976 694 318 1189 246 974 1125 523 247 1486 1071